Pauline authorship of Ephesians does not appear to
have been doubted in the early church. It is listed
among Paul's letters in the early manuscripts and cited
as such by early Christian authors such as Irenaeus (Against
Heresies 5.2.3), Clement of Alexandria (Stromateis
4.65), and Tertullian (Against
Marcion 5.11.17; 5.17.1). It is included among
Paul's letters as the Muratorian Canon, which is
generally regarded as second century, and acknowledged
as Paul's even by the heretic Marcion, who called it "Laodiceans."
Ephesians contains a carefully reasoned and precisely
worded theology presented in a systematic way. There is
no letter in the Pauline corpus that more precisely and
succinctly presents the rudimentary elements of his
understanding of salvation history than this one.
To grasp fully the theological core of this letter,
it is important to remember the nature of Paul's
conversion/call on the road to Damascus. He was told at
that time by the divine voice: "get up and stand on your
feet. I have appeared to you to appoint you as a servant
and as a witness of what you have seen of me and what I
will show you. I will rescue you from your own people
and from the Gentiles. I am sending you to them to open
their eyes and turn them from darkness to light, and
from the power of Satan to God, so that they may receive
forgiveness of sins and a place among those who are
sanctified by faith in me'" (Acts
26:16-18).
Paul's entire life after this experience was guided
by this commission he had received to take the gospel as
a Jew to the Gentiles (Gal
1:15-16). He functioned somewhat as a priestly
servant sent "to be a minister of Christ Jesus to the
Gentiles with the priestly duty of proclaiming the
gospel of God, so that the Gentiles might become an
offering acceptable to God, sanctified by the Holy
Spirit" (Rom
15:16).
The key to the theology of
Ephesians is the second chapter, where Paul sets forth
the implications of the equal union of Jews and Gentiles
in the one body, the church.
Both Gentiles (v. 1) and Jews (vv. 3-5) were once
dead in their trespasses and sins. Nevertheless, the
Jews had prepared the way for the Messiah and were the
first to be called into the church. The Gentiles have
since been included, largely by Paul's own work, in
keeping with divine forethought and election. God had
promised Abraham that his seed would be a blessing to
all the nations, and they must now be accepted fully as
equal partners in the kingdom.
It if foundational to the theology of Paul, in Acts
and in his generally accepted letters as well as in
Ephesians, that both Gentiles and Jews are made alive
together with Christ, have been raised up together, and
made to sit together with Christ in the heavenly places
(vv. 5-6). Thus, the Gentile disciples are fellow
citizens with the Jewish disciples and members together
with them of the household of God (v. 19).
The church, Paul argues, was built upon the Jewish
foundation of apostles and prophets, with Christ Jesus
as the chief (Jewish) cornerstone (2:20;
3:5). The Gentiles have now been included and, being
"joined together" with the Jewish foundation, they grow
together into a holy temple in the Lord (2:20-21).
Their daily moral and ethical conduct, which should be
guided by this truth, is set forth in the last part of
the letter (4:17-6:24).
A number of key theological terms and arguments in
Ephesians revolve around these two concepts: (1) the
historical and cosmological role of the Jews in God's
redemptive history from the time of Abraham; and (2)
Paul's own place in that process, that of bringing in
the Gentiles as full participants in the kingdom, which
evil forces in the cosmos conspired to prevent and thus
to destroy the work of Christ.
There is a distinctive emphasis in Ephesians on
Christ's exaltation above the heavens, his coronation at
the right hand of God, and his subsequent cosmic
lordship (1:3-4,
9-10, 20-23;
2:6;
4:8-10). The cosmological nature of the church being
the central emphasis of the theological section of the
letter (chap. 1-4), the author felt no need to argue
here for the resurrection of the body of Jesus and his
believers, which is of eschatological but not
cosmological import. He makes no mention of an imminent
return of Christ but rather speaks of the church's role
in manifesting the glory of Christ Jesus to all
generations. Aspects of the church's conduct until
Christ's return are delineated in chapters 5-6, as they
are is in Romans, Corinthians, Galatians, and
Thessalonians.
Israel as God's Elect. It is in the
context of the role of Israel as the elect, the chosen,
descended from Abraham to propagate the Messiah, rather
than in the context of individual predestination to
salvation, that Paul speaks of election. The first
chapter asserts that the Jews, God's saints or holy
ones, were "chosen" to bring the blessing of redemption
to all nations in fulfillment of the promise to Abraham.
It was the Jews who were foreordained unto adoption for
this purpose (v. 5), chosen in the beloved (Messiah) for
God's glory, that is, to declare the sovereignty of
monotheism, (v. 6), chosen before the foundation of the
world to be "holy and blameless" (v. 4). They were the
first to hope in the Messiah (v. 12).
The Specialized Application of Pronouns.
Another key to understanding Ephesians is
recognizing that in this book a Jewish author is writing
to a Gentile audience. This is especially evident in
Paul's discriminating use of first-person and
second-person pronouns. Although most studies on
Ephesians approach the letter by investigating its major
theological terms and comparing their use in Paul's
generally acknowledged letters, it is more likely that
the thinking of an author (or redactor) will be found in
those more commonly used parts of speech he employs at
times almost subconsciously. These parts of speech may
reflect the subconscious theological perspectives out of
which an author or redactor formulates his doctrine and
from which he expresses that doctrine. In this respect
the pronouns in Ephesians provide a key to the theology
of the book. If studied on the assumption of consistency
in use, they reveal the thinking of the author in a way
that allows us to draw important conclusions about the
point of view from which he writes and therefore about
his theology.
Paul consistently uses second-person pronouns in the
letter in a specialized sense, that of addressing an
exclusively Gentile Christian audience. The
particularized use of the second-person pronoun in
referring to Gentiles as the recipients of this letter
is seen in 2:11, where he says: "remember that you
who are Gentiles by birth and called
uncircumcision." Again in 3:1 he writes: "I, Paul, the
prisoner of Christ Jesus for the sake of you Gentiles."
However, unlike Romans, where Paul addresses his dual
audience on the one hand as Jews "who know the law" (7:1)
and then on the other as Gentiles (11:13),
Paul never addresses Jews directly in Ephesians using
the second-person pronoun.
First-person pronouns, like those in the second
person, are also used in a number of different ways,
both traditional and specialized. Their customary
epistolary use in personal communication may be seen in
6:12. They are also used in liturgical material and
confessional formulas. For example, in the greeting
"Grace to all who love our Lord Jesus Christ" (6:24)
the pronoun is part of a standard expression and has no
specialized reference.
Otherwise, the first-person plural pronouns, like the
second-person pronouns, are used in a specialized way.
In the first part of the letter, down to 2:3, they refer
to Jews or Jewish Christians. At this point, following
Paul's declaration of the inclusion of the Gentiles with
the Jews, the first-person pronouns henceforth refer to
Jews and Gentiles combined.
The significance of this pronoun use can be seen in
the following example. After the epistolary greeting in
1:1-2, the Gentiles are not referred to until verse 13,
where they are said to have been added to God's
redemptive work among the Jews, who thus far have been
designated by first-person plural pronouns. Paul then
addresses the Gentile readers in verse 13 by saying "you
heard the word of truth, the gospel of your
salvation … marked in him with a seal, the promised Holy
Spirit, who is a deposit guaranteeing our
inheritance."
Thus, the Jew and Gentile are differentiated by these
pronouns down to the second chapter.
Then in 2:1-5 , after the
declaration that the Gentiles now have been brought
together with the Jews into the body of Christ, the
first-person plural pronouns henceforth refer to Jews
and Gentiles together. The transition
point is verse 3, where Paul concludes that "all of
us [Jew and Gentile] also lived among them [the sons
of disobedience]."
Thus, the first ten verses of chapter 2 may be
paraphrased as follows: "You Gentiles were dead
in your trespasses and sins (v. 1) just as we
Jews were (v. 5), so we all shared the same guilt
of sin (v. 3). But God has now forgiven us (Jew
and Gentile alike) by his grace (vv. 6, 8), made us
alive together with Christ, raised us up
together and made us sit together with Christ
in the heavenly places" (vv. 5-8).
Therefore, from this point on (2:3)
the first-person plural pronouns include the Gentiles as
well, who have been grafted as wild olive branches into
the Jewish tree (Rom
11:17-24) and are henceforth, like the Jews,
included among the descendants of Abraham, "in order
that the blessing given to Abraham might come to the
Gentiles through Jesus Christ, so that by faith we
[Jew and Gentile] might receive the promise of the
Spirit" (Gal
3:14).
There are a number of
significant occurrences of the first-person plural
pronouns used in this inclusive way after 2:3, which
further clarify the theology of the letter.
The first example
and the most significant perhaps is in 2:5 where,
following three compound verbs describing the uniting of
Jews and Gentiles together in Christ ("made alive
together, raised together, and made to sit together"—sunezoopoiesen,
sunegeiren [sunegeivrw],
and sunekathisen), Paul states (v. 7) that God's
rich grace is manifested toward us, the
first-person plural pronoun now meaning Jew and Gentile
together, who are declared to be his workmanship (v.
10).
These compound verbs furnish a key point in the
theology of Ephesians. Most commentators on the Greek
text argue that chapter 1 deals with what God has done
for Christ and chapter 2 with what God has subsequently
done for all believers. These three compound verbs in
2:5 are thus taken to indicate the twofold union of
Christ and his believers.
However, all of them express difficulty in dealing
with the first five verses of chapter 2 and none of them
deals with the passage in the context of the thematic
consistency of pronoun use or sees the implausibility of
his position due to the demands of the three compound
verbs. The compounds themselves do not refer to any
union including Christ—Christ and Jews, Christ and
Gentiles, or Christ and Christians but to that of Jews
and Gentiles. The Jews and Gentiles thus brought
together, are then together, as an entity, united with
Christ.
The use of compounds in this
way occurs again in 3:6, where Paul says that the
Gentiles are fellow heirs (sunkleronoma)
fellow members of the body
(sussoma) and fellow
partakers (summetocha) of the promise in
Christ Jesus through the gospel.
The second example
of the special use of
first-person plural pronouns is in 2:16-18 where Paul
asserts that God has reconciled them both into
one body and created of the two one new person.
This statement of unification is then followed in verse
18 by a first-person plural construction referring to
the result of that unity: "we both have access to
the Father by one Spirit." The result is that the
Gentiles are now "fellow citizens with God's people, "
the Jews.
If this analysis is correct, 2:3 is the transition
point in the letter, with all the first-person pronouns
from this point on referring to the union of Jews and
Gentiles. Prior to this they refer to the Jews as a
people or to Jewish Christians. The third verse is the
decisive point, indicated by the phrase "we all"
which appears also in 4:13, in both instances expanding
the first-person pronoun references to Jews to include
the Gentiles as well.
That the author of Ephesians considers himself among
God's people and that they are Jewish Christians is
clear from 3:1, 8. In verse 1 he says "I, Paul, the
prisoner of Christ Jesus for the sake of you
Gentiles" and in verse 8 he continues "I am less than
the least of God's people." This distinction between
Gentiles and saints is seen also in 3:18, where the text
states: "in order that you (Gentiles) may have
power together with all the saints" the greatness
of God. It is significant that he does not say "with all
the other saints." Further, the mystery in 1:9,
which Paul says was made known to "us" (Jews), is
identified in 3:3-5 as a revelation to God's people
(Jews), that the Gentiles were to be fellow
participants in God's eternal purpose.
His perspective is that Satan, who dwells in the
region around the earth (2:2),
is actively trying to destroy the unity of the church.
The Christian warfare is with him, not with flesh and
blood. By
fostering disunity in the body
of Christ, as he did in the history of Israel, he
destroys its witness to the oneness of God (4:4-6),
which it constantly seeks to make known through its
unity, even to these principalities and powers in the
heavenly places (3:10).
The celestial world was highly structured in the
Hellenistic Jewish thought of Paul's time, having
multiple heavens, usually seven in number, and
containing both angels and demons. The major dogmas of
Jewish Christianity were developed along cosmological
lines, although they were concerned with Christology
rather than cosmology, and used cosmological data simply
as a medium of expression.
Paul speaks in Ephesians of multiple heavens, saying
that Christ ascended "higher than all the heavens" (4:10).
These heavenly places are not synonymous with "heaven"
because they include not only God and Christ, but also
Jewish and Gentile Christians, as well as demonic
powers (1:3,
10, 20;
2:2, 6;
3:10, 15;
4:10;
6:9, 12). Satan, the "ruler of the kingdom of the
air" (2:2)
dwells in a lower heaven around the earth known as the
firmament in Jewish apocalyptic thought.